Tuesday, June 21, 2011

Alphabet 5: Erasmus; Modern; Koine

Three major pronunciation systems

There are three major "how to pronounce Greek words" systems, each one having many little variations on the theme.
Some people very strongly prefer one system over the other. However, most are happy to find a system that works for them and for their teachers and fellow students of the Greek text.


Here are the three:


1. Erasmus.
The Erasmus system (often referred to as Erasmian, invented by Erasmus) in one form or another has been used in Bible college classrooms for centuries. It uses a set of made-up sounds. It's no surprise that it sounds artificial. It is!

The leading Biblical Greek textbook uses
this system. Marilyn Phemister's recording of the Greek NT uses this system; you can access her recording from the audio section on the right side of this blog page. Vocabulary aids often use this system, too; Visual Greek is an example.

Teachers know this system; students learn it.


This system uses a set of made-up sounds, intended to help students in the classroom to read and spell words (in this system, most vowel and vowel-pair sounds are unique, so knowing the sound usually helps one spell a word correctly). This set of sounds is good for reading or spelling a word at a time, yet has not proven to be as effective for oral reading, as it does not appear to have been designed with that readability in mind.

As a result, reading out loud in the classroom or listening to an audio recording, well, it sounds somewhat mechanical, somewhat odd, to the speaker and to the listener.

Many using this system go for years without ever reading a chapter aloud, with understanding. And when studying with others, reading a chapter aloud, well, it's just not done.

So while the Erasumus' system is helpful in reading a word or spelling a word, it may not provide enough "real language" connections for those who would like to actually read (and think) the Scriptures in Greek.

Many students begin their journey with this pronunciation system.


2. Modern.
Modern Greek is not a new language. It is Greek itself, developed over several millennia. It's pronunciation system is the historic outcome of a language living over such an extended time period.


Its sounds are the sounds of actual human language, developed over many centuries of oral and written communication.


John Simon's audio recording uses this system; you can access his recording from the audio section on the right side of this blog page.

3. Koine. In this approach, linguist Randall Buth began with modern Greek and adjusted it based upon what he observed from common misspellings during the centuries before, during, and after the first century A.D. (details
here). Buth is the innovator of a four-week immersion program, with two-week add-ons (details here and a participant's blog here).

This approach appears to be gaining more and more acceptance in the academic community.
Its sounds are the sounds that are justifiably the closest thing to what was spoken when the church epistles were read aloud to those who were part of the first-century church.


It's beautiful to the ear.

Some find that when wanting to read Greek aloud, or seeking to begin thinking in Greek, that the flowing sounds of a real language prove helpful, even essential.

Those who want to get to the point of "thinking and understanding in Greek" rather than "decoding and translating word by work into one's native tongue" are making the move from Erasmus sounds (where to date nearly everyone begins) to Koine sounds.

---

Q & A

Q: What did it sound like in the first century?
A: No one knows for sure. One may be able to get close by inferring some similar-in-sound matches from misspellings in handwritten manuscripts.

Q: Why choose Erasmus pronunciation?Pro: It's the one most often used in US classrooms and in learning materials.
Pro: Very few duplicate sounds makes it easier to hear a word and know how to write it down.
Con: It's a made-up systems of sounds, sounds that never existed together as an everyday language. It sounds awful! Yet is serves its purpose.


Q: Why choose modern Greek pronunciation?
Pro: The sounds you hear as you read aloud are the sounds of an actual human language, not an academic invention. It sounds like a real language. It sounds beautiful!
Con: It's used less frequently in US classrooms, although those who advocate it feel strongly about it.
Con: It's harder to hear a word and know how to write it down.

Q: Why choose Koine Greek pronunciation?
Pro: The sounds are as close as one can get to the sounds heard in the first-century church. It sounds like a real language. It sounds beautiful!

Con: It's used less frequently in US classrooms, although those who advocate it feel strongly about it.
Con: It's harder to hear a word and know how to spell it.


Q: Will my choice of Erasmus or Modern or Koine pronunciation affect my understanding of the Scriptures?
A: No. However, to the extent that using the sounds of an actual spoken language may help you think in that language, Koine Greek is likely to have an advantage.


Q: How might I choose?
A: Many begin with Erasmus, as that is what many learning materials are based upon, and that is what most peers may be familiar with. Then further along on one's journey, upgrading to Koine can be worthwhile, to facilitate actually reading, thinking, and meditating the Greek Scriptures.


Q: Which system does this site use?
A: The site supports and provides audio resources suitable for all three pronunciation systems.

---


Erasmus sounds
α | sound: ah | name: alpha (ahl.fah)
β | sound: b | name: beta (bey.tah)
γ | sound: g | name: gamma (gahm.mah)
δ | sound: d | name: delta (dehl.tah)
ε | sound: eh | name: epsilon (ehp.see.lahn)
ζ | sound: z | name: zeta (zey.tah)
η | sound: ey | name: eta (ey.tah)
θ | sound: th | name: theta (they.tah)
ι | sound: ee | name: iota (ee.oh.tah)
κ | sound: k | name: kappa (kahp.pah)
λ | sound: l | name: lambda (lahm.dah)
μ | sound: m | name: mu (moo)
ν | sound: n | name: nu (noo)
ξ | sound: ks | name: xi (ksee)
ο | sound: ah | name: omicron (ah.mee.krahn)
π | sound: p | name: pi (pee)
ρ | sound: r | name: rho (hroh)
σ, ς | sound: s | name: sigma (seeg.mah)
τ | sound: t | name: tau (tau)
υ | sound: oo | name: upsilon (oop.see.lahn)
φ | sound: f | name: phi (fee)
χ | sound: k | name: chi (kee)
ψ | sound: ps | name: psi (psee)
ω | sound: oh | name: omega (oh.meh.gah)
αι | sound: ahy (as in "αιsle")
αυ | sound: au (as in "sαυerkrαυt")
ει | sound: ey (as in "ειght")

ευ | sound: yoo (as in "fευd")
ηυ | sound: yoo (as in "fευd")
oι | sound: oi (as in "oιl")
oυ | sound: oo (as in "groυp")
υι | sound: wee (as in "sυιte")

γγ | sound: ng
γκ | sound: nk
γξ | sound: nks
γχ | sound: nk

‘ | sound: h

---

Modern sounds


α | sound: ah | name: alpha (ahl.fah)

β | sound: v | name: beta (vee.tah)

γ | sounds: gh | n before γκχ | y before eh or ee | name: gamma (ghahm.mah)
δ | sound: th | name: delta (thel.ta)
ε | sound: eh | name: epsilon (ehp.see.lohn)
ζ | sound: z | name: zeta (zee.tah)
η | sound: ee | name: eta (ee.tah)
θ | sound: th | name: theta (thee.tah)
ι | sound: ee | name: iota (yoh.tah)
κ | sound: k | name: kappa (kahp.pah)
λ | sound: l | name: lambda (lahm.dah)
μ | sound: m | name: mu (mee)
ν | sound: n | name: nu (nee)
ξ | sound: ks | name: xi (ksee)
ο | sound: oh | name: omicron (oh.mee.krohn)
π | sound: p | name: pi (pee)
ρ | sound: rolled r | name: rho (hroh)
σ, ς | sound: s | name: sigma (seeg.mah)
τ | sound: t | name: tau (tahf)
υ | sound: ee | name: upsilon (eep.see.lohn)
φ | sound: f | name: phi (fee)
χ | sound: kh | name: chi (kee)
ψ | sound: ps | name: psi (psee)
ω | sound: oh | name: omega (oh.meh.hgah)

αι | sound: eh
αυ | sounds: ahv | ahf (before θκξπστφχψ or final)
ει | sound: ee
ευ | sounds: ehv | ehf (before θκξπστφχψ or final)
ηυ | sounds: eev | eef (before θκξπστφχψ or final)
ιο | sound: yohoι | sound: eeoυ | sound: oo
υι | sound: ee


γγ | sound: ng
γκ | sound: ng (g, at word start)
γξ | sound: nks
γχ | sound: nk

μπ | sound: mb (b, at word start)
ντ | sound: nd (d, at word start)
τζ | sound: dz

‘ | sound: silent

---

Koine
sounds

Same as modern Greek, with these adjustments,
based upon papyrus and inscription evidence:


η | ey (rather than ee)

υ, οι | ue (rather than ee)
υι | ue.ee (two syllables)

Here are the Koine sounds:

α | sound: ah | name: alpha (ahl.fah)
β | sound: v | name: beta (vey.tah)

γ | sounds: gh | n before γκχ | y before eh or ee | name gamma (ghahm.mah|
δ | sound: th | name: delta (thel.ta)
ε | sound: eh | name: epsilon (ehp.see.lohn)
ζ | sound: z | name: zeta (zey.tah)
η | sound: ey | name: eta (ey.tah)
θ | sound: th | name: theta (they.tah)
ι | sounds: ee | name iota (ee.oh.tah)
κ | sound: k | name: kappa (kahp.pah)
λ | sound: l | name: lambda (lahm.dah)
μ | sound: m | name: mu (mue)
ν | sound: n | name: nu (nue)
ξ | sound: ks | name: xi (ksee)
ο | sound: oh | name: omicron (oh.mee.krohn)
π | sound: p | name pi (pee)
ρ | sound: rolled r | name: rho (hroh)
σ, ς | sound: s | name: sigma (seeg.mah)
τ | sound: t | name: tau (tahv)
υ | sound: ue | name: upsilon (uep.see.lohn)
φ | sound: f | name: phi (fee)
χ | sound: kh | name: chi (khee) | kh
ψ | sound: ps | name: psi (psee)
ω | sound: oh | name: omega (oh.meh.hgah)

αι | sound: eh
αυ | sounds: ahv | ahf (before θκξπστφκψ or final)
ει | sound: ee
ευ | sounds: ehv | ehf (before θκξπστφκψ or final)
ηυ | sounds: eyv | eyf (before θκξπστφκψ or final)

oι | sound: ueoυ | sound: oo
υι | sound: ue.ee (two syllables)


γγ | sound: ng
γκ | sound: nk
γξ | sound: nks
γχ | sound: nk

μπ | sound: b
ντ | sound: nd

‘ | sound: silent

---

©2015 TheBible.org All rights reserved worldwide.

Alphabet 4: Sing; Read; Write

Sing an Alphabet Song

Let's sing an alphabet song (click for audio)!


Here are the letters of the alphabet, along with how to pronounce the name of each letter and the sound each letter makes.
α | sound: ah | name: alpha (ahl.fah)
β | sound: b | name: beta (bey.tah)
γ | sound: g | name: gamma (gahm.mah)
δ | sound: d | name: delta (dehl.tah)
ε | sound: eh | name: epsilon (ehp.see.lahn)
ζ | sound: z | name: zeta (zey.tah)
η | sound: ey | name: eta (ey.tah)
θ | sound: th | name: theta (they.tah)
ι | sound: ee | name: iota (ee.oh.tah)
κ | sound: k | name: kappa (kahp.pah)
λ | sound: l | name: lambda (lahm.dah)
μ | sound: m | name: mu (moo)
ν | sound: n | name: nu (noo)
ξ | sound: ks | name: xi (ksee)
ο | sound: ah | name: omicron (ah.mee.krahn)
π | sound: p | name: pi (pee)
ρ | sound: r | name: rho (hroh)
σ, ς | sound: s | name: sigma (seeg.mah)
τ | sound: t | name: tau (tau)
υ | sound: oo | name: upsilon (oop.see.lahn)
φ | sound: f | name: phi (fee)
χ | sound: k | name: chi (kee)
ψ | sound: ps | name: psi (psee)
ω | sound: oh | name: omega (oh.meh.gah)

---

Read Aloud

Practice reading 1 Thes 1:2 aloud, slowly, syllable by syllable.

1 Thes 1:1
Παῦ¦λος  καὶ  Σι¦λου¦α¦νὸς  καὶ  Τι¦μό¦θε¦ος  τῇ  ἐκ¦κλη¦σί¦ᾳ  Θεσ¦σα¦λο¦νι¦κέ¦ων  ἐν  θε¦ πα¦τρὶ  καὶ  κυ¦ρί¦ῳ  Ἰ¦η¦σοῦ  Χρι¦στῷ·  χά¦ρις  ὑ¦μῖν  καὶ  εἰ¦ρή¦νη.

1 Thes 1:2

Εὐ¦χα¦ρι¦στοῦ¦μεν  τῷ  θε¦  πάν¦το¦τε  πε.ρὶ  πάν¦των  ¦μῶν,  μνεί¦αν  ποι¦ού¦με¦νοι  ¦πὶ τῶν  προ¦σευ¦χῶν  ¦μῶν,

Click for the audio of 1 Thes 1, read slowly, syllable by syllable.

---

Write the Alphabet

It's a good thing, knowing how to write down a Greek word, quickly.

While listening to a teaching, when you see a word group you find especially interesting, you can jot it down.

When studying in the morning, you can write down short phrase for the day:

1 Thes 1:2
Εὐ
¦χα¦ρι¦στοῦ¦μεν  τῷ  θε¦ῷ  πάν¦το¦τε...

You might find that things stick better in your head, if you see it, say it, write it (and key it in, when online).

The keys to writing Greek words quickly are:
- See if you can write each letter without lifting up your pencil (or lifting it just once)
- And some practice!

Here is a practice sheet (click for pdf).

Write 1 Thessalonians 1:2, saying the words aloud as you write them.

Memorize what may be your first verse in NT Greek:

1 Thes 5:16

πάν¦το¦τε  χαί¦ρε¦τε,
Always rejoice.

---

Little Notes

Transliteration:
it's an application of a mapping of letters in one alphabet into letters of another alphabet, as a convenience.
Here is such a mapping:

α | a
β | b
γ | g
δ | d
ε | e
ζ | z
η | ē
θ | th
ι | i

κ | k
λ | l
μ | m
ν | n
ξ | x
ο | o
π | p
ρ | r
σ ς | s
τ | t
υ | u
φ | ph
χ | ch
ψ | ps
ω | ō

Captial letters: The Greek alphabet also has capital letters. You'll see them at the start of sentences and at the start of proper names. And you'll find that you'll be able to read them, in their context--and that's a good way to begin to learn them. Like so:

1 Thes 1:1

Παῦλος  καὶ  Σιλουανὸς  καὶ  Τιμόθεος  τῇ  ἐκκλησίᾳ  Θεσσαλονικέων  ἐν  θεῷ  πατρὶ  καὶ κυρίῳ  Ἰησοῦ  Χριστῷ·  χάρις  ὑμῖν  καὶ  εἰρήνη.

In printed NT Greek texts, the book names for some reason or other are presented in all-capital Greek letters. You'll be able to understand the book name fairly quickly.

The Great Treasures site shows books names in a more usual fashion (more usual for the reader, that is): 
Πρὸς  Θεσσαλονικεῖς ά | to the Thessalonians alpha (that is to say: 1 Thessalonians)


Here is the alphabet, with regular letters and capital letters:

α | Α
β | Β
γ | Γ
δ | Δ
ε | Ε
ζ | Ζ
η | Η
θ | Θ
ι | Ι

κ | Κ
λ | Λ
μ | Μ
ν | Ν
ξ | Ξ
ο | Ο
π | Π
ρ | Ρ
σ ς | Σ
τ | Τ
υ | Υ
φ | Φ
χ | Χ
ψ | Ψ
ω | Ω

---


©2015 TheBible.org All rights reserved worldwide.

Alphabet 3: What's the Same, What's Different

Alphabet: What's the Same

Many letters in the Greek alphabet are what we are used to seeing in English--or at least close enough that it's easy to relate to them.

We've already seen that most of the vowels are lookalikes for the ones we see in English:

α, ε, ι, ο, υ look quite a bit like: a, e, i, o, u.

Now let's look at consonants that are "look alikes" for the ones we see in English:

β, δ, κ, λ, τ look quite a bit like: b, d, k, l (with some imagination), t.

β | sound: b | name: beta (bey.tah)
δ | sound: d | name: delta (dehl.tah)κ | sound: k | name: kappa (kahp.pah)
λ | sound: l | name: lambda (lahm.dah)τ | sound: t | name: tau (tau)

Alphabet: What's Different
Some Greek consonants don't look like anything we've seen before. That's okay. Time to get acquainted:


γ | sound: g | name: gamma (gahm.mah)
ζ | sound: z | name: zeta (zey.tah)
θ | sound: th | name: theta (they.tah)μ | sound: m | name: mu (moo)
ν | sound: n | name: nu (noo)
ξ | sound: ks | name: xi (ksee)
π | sound: p | name: pi (pee)
ρ | sound: r | name: rho (hroh)
σ, ς | sound: s | name: sigma (seeg.mah)
τ | sound: t | name: tau (tau)
φ | sound: f | name: phi (fee)
χ | sound: k | name: chi (kee)
ψ | sound: ps | name: psi (psee)

---

Note that some letters make two sounds in a row. Why? Often, this is what happens: the first sound ends one syllable; the second sound starts the next syllable. Like so:

δεξ¦ά¦με¦νοι| dehk.sah.meh.noi | after receiving
¦πε¦στρέψ¦ατε | eh.peh.strehp.sah.teh | you received

---

Sometimes a γ sounds like n, making a word easier to pronounce:
γγ | sound: ng
γκ | sound: nk
γξ | sound: nks
γχ | sound: nk

εὐ
¦αγ¦γέ¦λι¦ον | yoo.ahn.geh.lee.ahn | gospel

---

While getting started, it's helpful to remember:
- η sounds like ey (not n)
- ν sounds like n (not v)
- ρ sounds like r (not p)

---

©2015 TheBible.org All rights reserved worldwide.

Alphabet 2: Single-sound Vowel Pairs

Some vowel pairs are pronounced together, making just one sound.

αι | sound: ahy (as in "αιsle")
αυ | sound: au (as in "sαυerkrαυt")
ει | sound: ey (as in "ειght")

ευ | sound: yoo (as in "fευd")
ηυ | sound: yoo (as in "fευd")
oι | sound: oi (as in "oιl")
oυ | sound: oo (as in "groυp")
υι | sound: wee (as in "sυιte")

Here are some examples, one for each single-sound vowel pair:
| καί | kahy | and, also, even

| αὐ¦τοί | au.toi | they

εἰ¦ρή¦νη | ey.rey.ney | peace

| Εὐ¦χα¦ρι¦στοῦ¦μεν | yoo.kah.ree.stoo.mehn | we give thanks

| ¦δελ¦φοί | ah.dehl.foi | brothers

| ποι¦ού¦με¦νοι | poi.oo.meh.noi | making

| υἱ¦ός | hwee.ahs | son

The sounds of the single-sound vowel pairs are distinct.

However, note this overlap in sound:
- η is pronounced ey
- ει is pronounced ey
Pronounce all other vowel pairs with two sounds. 

For example:¦η¦σοῦ | ee.ey.soo | Jesus
Those two vowels (Ι.η) are not one of the single-sound vowel pairs. So pronounce the first sound, then the second sound (ee.ey).

---

Little Note


Diphthong: a vowel pair that is pronounced with a single sound.


---

©2015 TheBible.org All rights reserved worldwide.

Alphabet 1: Vowels and Marks

Some browser tips, before get started with the alphabet.

Sometimes it's helpful to see larger letters, especially to see the marks around a Greek word. Here's how to change the size:

Windows
- Press the Ctrl (control) key, and at the same time...- Press the + key (for larger letters) or the - key (for smaller letters)

Mac
- Press the Apple (command) key, and at the same time...
- Press the + key (for larger letters) or the - key (for smaller letters)

---

About the sounds of letters

Lessons 1-4 feature the Erasmus phonetic system.

Lesson 5 includes Erasmus, Modern, and Koine phonetic systems.

---

Vowels

α | sound: ah | name: alpha (ahl.fah)
ε | sound: eh | name: epsilon (ehp.see.lahn)
η | sound: ey | name: eta (ey.tah)
ι | sound: ee | name: iota (ee.oh.tah)
ο | sound: ah | name: omicron (ah.mee.krahn)υ | sound: oo | name: upsilon (oop.see.lahn)
ω | sound: oh | name: omega (oh.meh.gah)

Here are some practice words.All of these words occur in 1 Thessalonians 1:1-3, in various forms.

¦γά¦πη | ah.gah.pey | love

ἐλ¦πίς | ehl.pees | hope

ἐκ¦κλη¦σί¦α | ehk.kley.see.ah | church, assembly 

Χρι¦στός | kree.stahs |Christ 

λό¦γος | lah.gahs |word

κύ¦ρι¦ος | koo.ree.ahs | lord

¦μῶν | hoo.mohn, | of you

Marks

When in a word, Greek letters have some marks floating around them. Let's take a look at them.
1. The smooth breathing mark is silent; it appears over a starting vowel (or over the second vowel in a pair of starting vowels).


ἀ ἐ ἠ ἰ ὀ ὐ ὠ

2. The rough breathing mark adds an h sound at the beginning of a word; in the historically-adjusted system, this mark is silent.

ἁ ἑ ἡ ἱ ὁ ὑ ὡ ῥ


3. Accent marks help you say the word aloud, by showing which syllable to emphasize:

ά έ ή ί ό ύ ώ


ὰ ὲ ὴ ὶ ὸ ὺ ὼ

ᾶ ῆ ῖ ῶ


4. The iota subscript mark is silent, yet carries significance in meaning:

ᾳ ῃ ῳ

5. The apostrophe mark indicates some letters have dropped out, in fact, the remaining ending letter may have changed too. Why? So the pair of words are easier to read aloud together.

διά (dee.ah) is abbreviated as δι' in 1 Thes 1:5,
in this phrase: δι'  ὑμᾶς (dee hoo.mahs, dee ue.mahs)

ἀπό (ah.pah) is abbreviated as ἀφ' in 1 Thes 1:8,
in this phrase:
ἀφ'  ὑμῶν (ahf hoo.mohn, ahf ue.mohn)


6. Early Greek manuscripts have no punctuation. Punctuation was added later, as a convenience to the reader. The markings are different than the ones we are used to. Yet when encountered in context, punctuation is reasonably easy to figure out.

period .
comma ,
semicolon (half of a colon) ·
question mark (this is an odd one yet you'll know it in context) ; 

Rom 8:31 
...εἰ  ὁ  θε¦ὸς  ¦πὲρ  ¦μῶν,  τίς  καθ'  ¦μῶν;
ey hah theh.ahs hoo.pehr hey.mohn, tees kahth hey.mohn
If God for us, who against us?If God is for us, who is against us?


Rom 8:35

τίς  ¦μᾶς  χω¦ρί¦σει  ¦πὸ  τῆς  ¦γά¦πης  τοῦ  Χρι¦στο;...
tees hey.mahs koh.ree.sey ah.pah teys ah.gah.peys too kree.stoo
Who will separate us from the love of Christ?

7. Vowel-by-vowel dots. As we'll learn in the next lesson, some vowel pairs make just one sound. Yet some non-Greek words in the text don't follow this Greek convention. And so a pair of vowel-by-vowel dots go over the second vowel of such a vowel pair, so that the foreign word is pronounced vowel-by-vowel. Here is an example:


1 Thes 1:8

 ...¦χα¦ΐ¦...
ah.kah.ee.ah


8. Syllables. The Great Treasures site displays syllables, making it easier to begin reading the text. It marks syllable breaks with bars (ex¦am¦ple), a feature that can be turned on or off whenever you choose.

---

Little Notes


Mark names: The formal names of the marks are:

ἀ smooth breathing

ἁ rough breathing

ά acuteὰ grave (grahv)

ᾶ circumflex

ᾳ iota subscript' elision (ih-lihz-uhn)


ϊ diaeresis (dahy-er-uh-sihs)

---

©2015 TheBible.org All rights reserved worldwide.